LNG from the U.S. is set to do battle in Europe but Russia's Gazprom is setting the stage, preparing a cold reception for the super-cooled gas set to cross the Atlantic.
A weakened rouble has lowered Gazprom's production costs by one-fifth, while its profits on dollar-denominated gas sales to Europe last year doubled in rouble terms. Gazprom has managed to increase sales despite a push by the EU to curb Russian energy imports, using discounts, renegotiation of unpopular oil-linked contracts and gas sales via auctions.
Spurring Gazprom's charm offensive is a looming showdown as a wave of U.S. gas is set to reach Europe's shores beginning next year.
U.S. exporters led by Cheniere Energy Inc. are expected to have 83 billion cubic meters (Bcm) of gas ready for sale by 2019. That's about 20% of Europe's current annual gas needs. That threatens to exacerbate already significant global gas oversupply, with new producers squaring up against established players for market share and driving prices lower.
"We are at the start of a new chapter in European gas markets," Fatih Birol, executive director at the International Energy Agency (EIA), said recently as the U.S. and other suppliers fight to gain access.
But Gazprom for now appears confident it can see off the challenge and even raise its European market share, which stood at 31% in 2015, helped by declining output in Europe, primarily in the Netherlands and Britain.
As U.S. producers crank up exports, more than a dozen LNG cargoes have been exported, yet so far just one has reached Europe as other markets offer better returns.
"Longer-term, Asia will remain more attractive for U.S. gas. No U.S. businessman in the right state of mind--being already heavily indebted and having put all his assets as collateral with banks--will deliver gas to Europe at a loss," Gazprom's Deputy CEO Alexander Medvedev told Reuters last week.
Lesson Learned?
However, Gazprom has been wrong before. A few years ago it was similarly skeptical about the threat posed by the rise of U.S. shale gas and oil.
CEO Alexei Miller said, at the time, that unconventional gas was expensive to produce and would not be a game-changer in the global energy market. That was a serious miscalculation and proved costly as Gazprom was forced to shelve development of one of the world's largest gas fields, Shtokman, as shale rapidly wiped out U.S. needs for gas imports.
Russian President Vladimir Putin subsequently urged Gazprom to rethink its long-term export policy to take advantage of rising demand in Asian markets.
But as the company's pivot to Asia drags, Gazprom has looked to bolster demand in Europe through discounting and renegotiating its 25-year oil-linked supply deals.
After years of tough negotiations, it has reached deals with long-term buyers including France's Engie and Germany's Uniper, a unit of E.ON.
Cheaper oil prices have helped lower Russian gas prices, and that has spurred demand, with Gazprom deliveries to Europe and Turkey up 20% in 2016's first quarter.
"Russian gas is low-cost and will remain below U.S. gas prices," said Claudio Descalzi, CEO of Italy's Eni, the biggest buyer of Russian gas in Europe.
And Gazprom seems willing to fight for greater share of the EU market, given dwindling sales in former Soviet states, and still-distant prospects of piping gas to China, according to Poland's Centre for Eastern Studies.
Price Focus
European gas hub prices stand at around 35 pence/therm currently. A fall to 21 pence would hurt Gazprom's margins but, more critically, would make it unprofitable for U.S. supplies to cross the Atlantic.
As much as half the production capacity of U.S. LNG players could be shut-in during the summer and at other times if Gazprom simply keeps flowing gas to Europe at current rates, said analyst Stephen O'Rourke at consultancy Wood Mackenzie.
Gazprom has 100 Bcm per year of spare production capacity at its disposal, or roughly one-quarter of Europe's annual needs, according to the Oxford Institute of Energy Studies.
And like Saudi Arabia has done in oil, Gazprom has shown it can use its market dominance to squeeze its competitors.
After Lithuania opened its Independence LNG import terminal at the end of 2014, for example, Gazprom cut prices to Lithuania and has held an auction for the Baltic states in a bid to boost consumption.
Estonia also took more gas from Russia earlier this year, taking advantage of Gazprom prices that were down by about 45%, data from grid operator Elering showed.
"We have such low production costs that we will always be able to cut the selling price by a dollar or two when it comes to fighting off a rival," said a senior source at Gazprom.
Gazprom might win the war but it cannot win every battle.
Ukrainian state energy firm Naftogaz recently said it would likely ignore a Russian offer of gas supplies for next winter, citing prices it said were higher than those offered from Europe.
However, an all-out offensive to grab continental market share by lowering prices would have a cost for Gazprom, too. It would not only squeeze Gazprom's own profits, but would also risk drawing strong political reaction from the European Commission and EU states.
As a result, Gazprom is likely to keep supplies steady at current levels hoping to see off any new wave of U.S. LNG project investment, said Anna Galtsova, associate director at IHS' Russian and Caspian Energy group.
Recommended Reading
Coterra’s Rigs ‘Stay Camped Out’ in Delaware Basin Mega-DSU Drilling
2025-02-26 - With 57 wells already in one “row” development, Coterra Energy has 16 more underway, plus rigs at work on two more mega-DSU developments totaling 90 wells.
PHX Minerals Explores Sale After Rejecting Acquisition Bids
2024-12-13 - PHX Minerals hired bankers to explore a potential merger or sale of the firm, which manages assets across the Midcontinent and Haynesville Shale play. PHX has rejected multiple unsolicited acquisition bids in the past two years.
DUCs Fly the Coop: Big Drawdowns from the Midland to Haynesville
2025-02-14 - The Midland Basin depleted its inventory of excess DUCs the most last year, falling from two months of runway to one during the past year, according to a report by Enverus Intelligence Research.
PRB’s Sage Butte Ready for M&A Across Lower 48, Maybe Canada Too
2025-01-08 - Private E&P Sage Butte Energy, which operates in the Powder River Basin, is less interested in the Permian Basin, citing the cost of entry.
Less Flaring, More Bitcoin: Startup Catches Eye of Halliburton Labs
2024-12-31 - 360 Energy, a startup that sets up generators on pad sites and uses the electricity for cryptocurrency, has recently caught the attention of Halliburton Labs.