![](/sites/default/files/styles/hart_news_article_image_640/public/image/2019/02/atherton.jpg?itok=8djGYYyf)
Chris Atherton, president of asset-marketing firm EnergyNet, addresses Hart Energy's recent A&D Strategies and Opportunities conference in Dallas. (Source: Hart Energy)
DALLAS—Asset sales by distressed E&Ps have been few relative to the number of bankruptcy filings to date. However, this may change going forward due to continued low oil price, according to Chris Atherton, president of asset-marketing firm EnergyNet.
“I think there will be considerable assets for sale by these companies after they emerge from Chapter 11,” Atherton said at Hart Energy’s recent A&D Strategies and Opportunities conference.
Since year-end 2014, more than 100 North American oil producers have filed for bankruptcy as of Sept. 9, according to law firm Haynes and Boone LLP’s “Oil Patch Bankruptcy Monitor.”
Debt-for-equity exchanges by troubled oil and gas producers have given these companies more time to wait out sub-$50 oil and sub-$3 natural gas, Atherton said.
“Many people thought the A&D market would be flooded with assets in 2015 and into 2016 from bankruptcies and that it would be an extraordinary opportunity for buyers with dry powder,” he said.
Debt-for-equity exchanges have given troubled operators more time, however. “We all expected an onslaught of bankrupt assets on the market, but … it’s being deferred into the future,” Atherton said.
Buyers should be careful of buying assets from sellers that may still file Chapter 11, he added.
“Buying assets pre-bankruptcy has its pros and cons. Obviously, it is faster. You don’t have a judge overseeing it,” he said. Also, the deal structure may be more flexible and the process may be less expensive.
But, if the seller does end up in bankruptcy court, “the court could deem it a fraudulent transfer and try to claw back those assets,” he said.
The transaction would be seen more favorably if the sale process had been competitive. “It would help to have information that it was a marketed process,” he said.
Post-filing by the distressed asset-owner, buying assets from bankruptcy court as the “stalking horse” bidder—known as a 363 sale—is the most popular process. In this, a prospective buyer has already put in a bid.
“Once you are the stalking horse, you are a kind of bird-in-hand to the creditors and to the entity. They don’t have a whole lot of initiative to find someone who is going to top your bid,” Atherton said.
The court may still shop for other bids, but, “most of the time, the stalking horse is the buyer of the asset. You want to be in that position,” he said.
A recent exception was Rice Energy Inc.’s (NYSE: RICE) $200 million bid this past spring for coal operator Alpha Natural Resources Inc.’s Marcellus and Utica leasehold.
Vantage Energy Inc. won Alpha’s assets for $340 million in an auction. Vantage has since filed an S-1 to go public with its portfolio, which includes Barnett shale properties.
“Rice was able to get the break-up fee,” which was up to $3.5 million, but it had already sold shares to fund the acquisition for net proceeds of $312 million. “It wasn’t a good outcome for them,” Atherton said.
The challenges of buying out of bankruptcy court include the financial commitment that may prevent the prospective buyer from participating in other acquisitions.
“You may feel bogged down in the process,” Atherton said. It is also “slow and painful. Be ready for delays.” Still, “you want to get your foot in the door. Be the bird-in-hand.”
Buyers of assets out of Chapter 11 proceedings have included:
- BlueStone Natural Resources LLC from Quicksilver Resources Inc. ($2 billion of debt);
- Texegy LLC from Swift Energy Co. ($1.2 billion);
- BXP Partners LP from Argent Energy Trust and its U.S. subsidiary ($205 million);
- Resource Energy LLC from American Eagle Energy Corp. ($194 million);
- Scout Energy Partners LP from Parallel Energy LP ($170 million);
- White Oak Energy LLC from Milagro Oil & Gas Inc. ($1.1 billion); and
- White Marlin Oil & Gas Co. LLC from Dune Energy Inc. ($108 million).
Operators who remain in bankruptcy court currently include:
- Linn Energy LLC ($6.1 billion of debt) and subsidiary Berry Petroleum Co. LLC ($1.8 billion);
- Ultra Petroleum Corp. ($3.8 billion);
- Pacific Exploration & Production Corp. ($5.3 billion);
- Energy XXI Ltd. ($2.8 billion);
- SandRidge Energy Inc. ($8.3 billion); and
- BreitBurn Operating LP ($5.8 billion).
Atherton said few producers’ balance sheets were prepared for this extended commodity price downturn.
“Just about every E&P company after Thanksgiving Day of 2014 became distressed,” he said.
Among North American producers who have filed for bankruptcy-court protection, their secured and unsecured debt is some $68 billion, according to the Haynes and Boone count, as of early September. Among them, 58 were able to manage through year-end 2015, but persistently low commodity prices and upcoming debt maturities resulted in imminent default. Those filing in bankruptcy court this year owed $50 billion to creditors.
The law firm reported that “despite the recent spike in oil prices,” which drove the prompt-month WTI contract past $47 on Sept. 8, “all indications suggest more producer bankruptcy filings will occur during 2016.”
Nissa Darbonne can be reached at ndarbonne@hartenergy.com.
Recommended Reading
Midcon Momentum: SCOOP/STACK Plays, New Zones Draw Interest
2024-09-03 - The past decade has been difficult for the Midcontinent, where E&Ps went bankrupt and pulled back drilling activity. But bountiful oil, gas and NGL resources remain untapped across the Anadarko, the SCOOP/STACK plays and emerging zones around the region.
Darbonne: ‘The Dance’ of US Policy Leaving Energy Mid Slip
2024-09-02 - The 1909 Matisse painting known as “The Dance” demonstrates the outcome of one of the U.S.’ pillars falling down.
Analyst: US NGL Market Tightens Links to Crude, NatGas Production
2024-09-02 - A boost in propane and ethane development is tied to the opening of the Matterhorn Pipeline in the Permian, evidence of the increasingly closer link between different sectors of the energy industry.
EDF Renewables Secures Investment in Solar Energy Storage Project
2024-09-02 - Power Sustainable Energy Infrastructure acquired a 50% stake in EDF Renewables North America’s Desert Quartzite Solar+Storage Project in California.
Energy Transition in Motion (Week of Aug. 30, 2024)
2024-08-30 - Here is a look at some of this week’s renewable energy news, including a more than $2 billion hydrogen and atmospheric gases facility in the works.