A three-judge panel struck down four pipeline safety rules issued by the U.S. Department of Transportation in 2022.
The Interstate Natural Gas Association of America (INGAA) celebrated the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision on August 16. The organization had brought the suit against five new regulations, claiming the new rules did not provide enough benefits to justify the costs associated with implementation.
The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), a division of the Department of Transportation, has 40 days to request a re-hearing from the appeals court.
“INGAA is pleased with the outcome of this case,” said Ben Kochman, INGAA’s director of pipeline safety policy, in an email to Hart Energy. “We look forward to working with PHMSA on continuing our efforts to improve pipeline safety, building upon the alternatives we proposed throughout the rulemaking process.”
The rules challenged in the suit were part of an overall safety rules package that PHMSA developed over a decade-long process, usually with support from the INGAA. The rules were primarily concerned with protecting the public from pipeline corrosion.
The court allowed one rule in the suit to stand, a regulation for monitoring a type of pipe anomaly that occurs when corrosion and high pressure causes cracks, Reuters reported.
“We agree with INGAA that the agency failed to adequately explain why the benefits of the final standards outweigh their costs,” wrote Judge Florence Pan, one of the judges on the panel. “Because the agency imposed a new safety requirement without properly addressing the costs of doing so, the standard cannot stand.”
According to the ruling, the appeals court fully vacated the four standards. To put the laws back on the books, the Department of Transportation will have to start a new rulemaking effort with a cost/benefit analysis that meets the court’s approval.
Recommended Reading
The EPC Market Keeps Its Head Above Water
2024-08-06 - While offshore investments are rising, particularly in deepwater fields, challenges persist due to project delays and inflation, according to Westwood analysis.
BP and NGC Sign E&P Deal for Offshore Venezuelan Cocuina Field
2024-07-28 - BP and NGC signed a 20-year agreement to develop Venezuela’s Cocuina offshore gas field, part of the Manakin-Cocuina cross border maritime field between Venezuela and Trinidad and Tobago.
How Liberty Rolls: Making Electricity, Using NatGas to Fuel the Oilfield
2024-08-22 - Liberty Energy CEO Chris Wright said the company is investing in keeping its frac fleet steady as most competitors weather a downturn in oil and gas activity.
Southeast Asia NatGas Projects Could Unlock $100B Boom- Rystad
2024-07-17 - Southeast Asia's offshore gas industry is set for a $100 billion boom by 2028, driven by a flurry of final investment decisions by oil and gas majors and national oil companies, according to Rystad Energy.
Chevron Pushing Longer Laterals in Argentina’s Vaca Muerta Shale
2024-09-13 - Chevron Corp., already drilling nearly 2.8-mile laterals at its Loma Campana Field in Argentina, wants to drill even longer horizontals, an executive told Hart Energy.
Comments
Add new comment
This conversation is moderated according to Hart Energy community rules. Please read the rules before joining the discussion. If you’re experiencing any technical problems, please contact our customer care team.