The toxic gas ethylene oxide (EtO) is detectable in southeastern Louisiana at levels a thousand times higher than what is considered safe, according to a new study.
EtO emissions largely come from petrochemical manufacturing, and southeastern Louisiana has a high density of facilities that use or manufacture petrochemicals.
“We expected to see ethylene oxide in this area,” said study leader Peter DeCarlo of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore. “But we didn’t expect the levels that we saw, and they certainly were much, much higher” than levels estimated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
EPA estimates were based on traditional EtO monitoring methods that involve collecting air samples and analyzing them in a lab, a method that is not precise, DeCarlo said.
Because EtO concentrations change over time, the air that comes out of the collection canister in the lab is different from the air that was originally collected, he explained.
In February 2023, researchers crisscrossed repeatedly through southeastern Louisiana’s industrial corridor with a cutting-edge mobile air-testing lab that could directly measure EtO levels on site.
EtO is so toxic that dangerous levels for long-term exposure start at 11 parts per trillion, the researchers noted in a report published on Tuesday in the journal Environmental Science & Technology.
Levels in southeastern Louisiana reached 40 parts per billion near industrial facilities, “more than a thousand times higher than the accepted risk for lifetime exposure,” DeCarlo said.
“I don’t think there’s any census tract in the area that wasn’t at higher risk for cancer than we would deem acceptable,” DeCarlo said.
Long-term exposure has been linked to cancer, particularly for people living near facilities that manufacture EtO or work with it.
Concerning levels were found up to 6 miles (10 km) downwind from factories, according to the report.
One public school in Gonzales, Louisiana is only 5 miles (8 km) from the center of one industrial “hotspot,” the researchers said.
The EPA said it would review the study. It added that it had already taken steps to reduce pollution in the part of the state nicknamed “Cancer Alley” due to its higher cancer incidence rates, including by setting new standards for chemicals manufacturing and by conducting research into sources of EtO.
A spokesperson for the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers, which represents the U.S. petrochemicals and oil refining industry, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
High cancer rates in the area connected to local industrial air pollution disproportionately affect impoverished and black neighborhoods. DeCarlo said his team has been sharing their findings with these neighborhoods.
“Now we have data for them that will help them bring their concerns forward” to public health authorities, he said.
Recommended Reading
TXOGA Supports Ruling to Pause Biden’s Pause
2024-07-02 - The Texas Oil & Gas Association (TXOGA), the oldest and largest oil and gas trade association in Texas, sided with a Louisiana judge’s ruling to pause U.S. President Joe Biden’s pause of LNG permits.
Supreme Court’s Uinta Basin Rail Case Raises Stakes for LNG, Pipelines
2024-07-10 - The lawsuit, involving crude transport via railway in the Uinta Basin, is part of a larger intragovernmental fight that could have implications for how FERC decides pipeline and LNG plant permitting.
Williams Cos. Blasts Energy Transfer’s FERC Filing
2024-05-15 - In response to Energy Transfer, Williams says the rival’s action is “lawfare” to delay the company’s Louisiana Energy Gateway project.
Zachry Proposes Settlement Agreement to End Golden Pass LNG Standoff
2024-07-22 - Zachry, an engineering contractor for the Golden Pass LNG project, submitted a settlement agreement in bankruptcy court that would allow Exxon Mobil and QatarEnergy to move forward with the delayed project.
Saudi Aramco Holding LNG Talks with US Firms Tellurian, NextDecade, Sources Say
2024-06-04 - Oil giant Aramco is in talks with Tellurian to buy a stake in the Driftwood LNG plant near Lake Charles, Louisiana.