The war of words between Williams Cos. Inc. (NYSE: WMB) and Energy Transfer Equity LP (NYSE: ETE) has worsened after Williams filed a lawsuit to pressure its would-be buyer to proceed with their merger agreement.
Williams has accused Energy Transfer Equity of trying to get out of the $20 billion deal and filed a lawsuit late on May 13 seeking to prevent the Dallas-based firm from terminating its takeover over a tax issue or if the deal isn't closed by a June 28 deadline.
Williams said in a statement that Energy Transfer Equity has used "delay and obstruction" to try and wriggle out of its agreement. Energy Transfer Equity responded on May 15 by saying the lawsuit was an attempt to gain leverage in any future deal talks between the two companies and would delay any progress.
"ETE is disappointed that Williams, rather than seriously engaging in discussions regarding the existing transaction, has chosen to file a third separate lawsuit in the last six weeks regarding our pending merger," Kelcy Warren, Energy Transfer Equity's CEO, said in a statement.
Williams declined to comment.
The lawsuit is the latest twist in what has been a testy transaction almost from the get-go.
Dallas billionaire Warren set his sights on Tulsa, Okla.-based Williams last year to transform his empire into one of the world's biggest pipeline networks, launching an unsolicited bid in June and reaching a deal in late September that was then worth around $33 billion.
The timing was poor. Oil and gas prices dropped significantly after it was announced, the companies' shares dropped sharply and investors started to worry that the $6 billion cash portion of the deal would saddle Energy Transfer Equity with too much debt.
But the Williams' board, which was initially split on the transaction, came out in support of the deal as oil prices spiralled further south.
Tax Issue
Warren said on May 15 that circumstances had changed since the companies struck their deal, and suggested that Williams' board should revisit its recommendation that shareholders vote in favor of the merger.
Warren said that Williams has prevented Energy Transfer Equity from reaching out to its board and did not respond to its requests before filing the latest lawsuit.
In recent weeks, Energy Transfer Equity has said that it can't complete the acquisition because its lawyers can't guarantee that the deal will be a tax-free transaction for Williams shareholders. Obtaining a favorable opinion on the tax issue from Energy Transfer's lawyers is a requirement for the deal to close.
Williams has said it disagrees with the lawyers' assessment of the tax risks. It has remained steadfast to the original terms.
The stand-off, preceded by a lawsuit and a countersuit both alleging breaches of the agreement, underscores how acrimonious relations have gotten between the two sides.
Warren has said Energy Transfer Equity would be open to a deal that would remove the cash portion of its cash-and-stock offer for Williams.
Energy Transfer Equity has slashed its estimates for cost savings from the deal and warned it would likely have to cut its distributions to shareholders entirely next year if it has to complete it. The company has also said that it will have to cut jobs substantially in Williams' home state of Oklahoma.
RELATED:
Will Tax Issue Be Dagger Through Heart Of ETE-Williams Merger?
Energy Transfer Partners’ Long Pursuit Of Williams Ends With $38 Billion Ring
Recommended Reading
Analyst: Is Jerry Jones Making a Run to Take Comstock Private?
2024-09-20 - After buying more than 13.4 million Comstock shares in August, analysts wonder if Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones might split the tackles and run downhill toward a go-private buyout of the Haynesville Shale gas producer.
BP Profit Falls On Weak Oil Prices, May Slow Share Buybacks
2024-10-30 - Despite a drop in profit due to weak oil prices, BP reported strong results from its U.S. shale segment and new momentum in the Gulf of Mexico.
SM Energy Adds Petroleum Engineer Ashwin Venkatraman to Board
2024-12-04 - SM Energy Co. has appointed Ashwin Venkatraman to its board of directors as an independent director and member of the audit committee.
Utica Oil E&P Infinity Natural Resources Latest to File for IPO
2024-10-05 - Utica Shale E&P Infinity Natural Resources has not yet set a price or disclosed the number of shares it intends to offer.