NEW YORK—The operators of the Dakota Access oil pipeline (DAPL) argued to a federal court on April 19 that the system’s shutdown would be even more harmful than previously anticipated, in their final plea to keep the line open after a key permit was scrapped.
The operators, led by Energy Transfer, told the U.S. District Court of the District of Columbia that an “immediate economic shock” would occur if the line were shut during a court-ordered environmental review. The company’s revenue losses while closed would be 10% higher than previously projected, at between $3.44 million and $4.28 million per day, they said.
The 570,000 barrel-per-day (bbl/d) DAPL pipeline began operating in 2017 but has been locked in legal battles with Native American tribes and activists since before the line started construction.
Last year, the D.C. Court canceled a permit allowing DAPL to operate below the Lake Oahe waterway in North and South Dakota. DAPL is the biggest system carrying oil from the Bakken shale basin of North Dakota and Montana.
The court also ordered the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to conduct an environmental review, expected to be completed in March 2022, that will determine whether the line remains permanently open.
The current filing is hoping to sway Judge James Boasberg to keep DAPL open during that process.
The tribes argue that DAPL endangers their water supply from Lake Oahe.
Dakota Access says the line meets the energy needs of the Midwest and Gulf Coast and provides for the economies of North Dakota and other states.
The Corps of Engineers has not sought to shut the line.
The tribes must tell the court by April 23 whether they will respond to DAPL’s filing. A decision on the tribes’ request for the shutdown is expected in May.
Recommended Reading
Exxon CEO Darren Woods: Hydrogen Incentives ‘Critical’ for Now
2025-02-03 - Exxon Mobil CEO Darren Woods said the end goal for energy policy should be a system in which no fuel source remains dependent on government subsidies.
CEO: TotalEnergies to Expand US LNG Investment Over Next Decade
2025-02-06 - TotalEnergies' investments could include expansion projects at its Cameron LNG and Rio Grande LNG facilities on the Gulf of Mexico, CEO Patrick Pouyanne said.
US Tariffs on Canada, Mexico Hit an Interconnected Crude System
2025-03-04 - Canadian producers and U.S. refiners are likely to continue at current business levels despite a brewing trade war, analysts say.
Trump Fires Off Energy Executive Orders on Alaska, LNG, EVs
2025-01-21 - President Donald Trump opened his term with a flurry of executive orders, many reversing the Biden administration’s policies on LNG permitting, the Paris Agreement and drilling in Alaska.
Dell: Folly of the Forecast—Why DOE’s LNG Study Will Invariably Be Wrong
2025-01-07 - Kimmeridge’s Ben Dell says the Department of Energy’s premise that increased LNG exports will raise domestic natural gas prices ignores a market full of surprises.