[Editor's note: This story was updated at 10:35 p.m. CDT May 30.]
SandRidge Energy Inc. (NYSE: SD) warned shareholders on May 29 they would be handing control of the company too cheaply to activist investor Carl Icahn if they elect his new nominees to the board at an annual meeting next month.
Icahn earlier in May added two more nominees to his slate, demanding yet more influence after the company expanded its board to seven directors from five to accommodate the activist investor's demands.
In a letter to shareholders, SandRidge CEO William Griffin said the billionaire investor, who has said he could make an all-cash offer for the company, was not competing "fairly with other potential counterparties."
RELATED: Corvex, Carl Icahn To Mull Takeover Bid For Energen
An Icahn-led board would "likely have a chilling effect on the participation of potential counterparties because such a process would be rigged in favor of Icahn," Griffin said.
Icahn has made a career out of shaking up company management and, as the biggest shareholder in SandRidge with a 13.6% stake, he has already forced the resignation of both its CEO and CFO.
SandRidge's shares, however, have fallen more than 15% since Icahn disclosed his stake on Nov. 21 and the jury is still out on how new management—or sales of company assets—would deliver more value to shareholders.
A slump in oil prices and its exposure to costly production in the Mississippi Lime forced the Oklahoma City-based oil producer briefly into bankruptcy proceedings in 2016.
Oil prices have since recovered to $80 a barrel for the first time since 2014 and shale producers in the U.S. have benefited from cheaper drilling methods and ever-increasing global demand.
The question is whether SandRidge now has a better spread of drilling sites to take advantage of the rise.
David Beard, analyst at Coker Palmer Institutional, said while short-term investors often penalize the valuations of companies with current, declining production, Icahn is betting on SandRidge's undrilled locations in the hope that those will bring the production levels up.
"SandRidge operates in a relatively higher cost Mississippi Lime basin, thus the downturn hurt them particularly hard, having to drop almost all their rigs. This placed downward pressure on production," Beard said.
"But should production grow and undrilled locations become valuable, we can see net asset values approach about $50/sh."
June Showdown
Icahn initially persuaded SandRidge's leadership to back out of a $746 million deal with rival Bonanza Creek Energy Inc. (NYSE: BCEI) but he has now spent months laying into its management.
In April, the billionaire nominated Jonathan Frates and Nicholas Graziano—both of whom work for Icahn companies—to SandRidge's board.
The other three nominees are John Lipinski and Bob Alexander who have worked with refining company CVR Energy Inc. and Randolph Read, who has worked with investment fund Nevada Strategic Credit Investment.
Ahead of the June 19 shareholders meeting, Griffin said Icahn's continuous additions to the board would "end the impartial process, drive away competition and position Icahn to consolidate control as cheaply as possible."
Icahn's involvement and pressuring of Newell Brands Inc. to appoint four of his nominees to its board ran parallel to the company's shares recovering some of last year's almost 50% loss. They have since retreated to back to near record lows.
Icahn's move with fellow shareholder Darwin Deason to prevent Xerox Corp. merging with Fujifilm Holdings have seen shares in the photocopying icon fall around 25% from a three-year high hit when the deal was announced in January.
Icahn did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Recommended Reading
Expand’s Dell’Osso: US LNG Facilities May Fall Below Capacity in ‘26
2025-03-04 - CEO Nick Dell’Osso said Expand Energy wants to time drilling and completion spending and grow gas output to meet a flush LNG market.
Expand CFO: ‘Durable’ LNG, Not AI, to Drive US NatGas Demand
2025-02-14 - About three-quarters of future U.S. gas demand growth will be fueled by LNG exports, while data centers’ needs will be more muted, according to Expand Energy CFO Mohit Singh.
Bernstein Expects $5/Mcf Through 2026 in ‘Coming US Gas Super-Cycle’
2025-01-16 - Bernstein Research’s team expects U.S. gas demand will grow from some 120 Bcf/d currently to 150 Bcf/d into 2030 as new AI data centers and LNG export trains come online.
Gas-Fired Power Plants Create More Demand for Haynesville Shale
2025-03-04 - Expansions and conversions of Gulf Coast power plants are taking advantage of the plentiful Haynesville Shale gas.
NatGas Prices, E&Ps Take a Hit from DeepSeeking Missile
2025-01-28 - E&Ps such as Expand Energy and EQT Corp. saw share prices drop on news of less power-intensive AI, but analysts predict the natural gas market will rebound as LNG exports and overall power demand continues to increase.