If OPEC thought the 26% drop in oil prices since October might rein in U.S. shale production like the last sharp drop did four years ago, it might have to think again.
U.S. shale firms are more profitable than ever after a strong third quarter, according to a Reuters analysis of results for 32 independent producers. These companies are producing more efficiently, generating more cash flow and consolidating in a wave of mergers, the data show.
Results at 32 independent shale explorers show nearly a third generated more cash from operations than they spent on drilling and shareholder payouts, a group including Devon Energy Corp. (NYSE: DVN), EOG Resources Inc. (NYSE: EOG) and Continental Resources Inc. (NYSE: CLR). A year ago, there were just three companies on that list.
RELATED: Corporate Oil And Gas M&A Gains Altitude After $13 Billion Week
The group's cash flow deficit has narrowed to $945 million as U.S. benchmark crude hit $70 a barrel and production soared. The group overspent by three times as much as recently as June and was $4.92 billion in the hole a year ago, according to Reuters' analysis of Morningstar data provided by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
The change is evidence shale firms have moved to "harvest mode" after shareholders pressured them to rein in spending and increase payouts, said Shawn Reynolds, a portfolio manager at asset firm VanEck. "The industry is starting to do that."
OPEC's Worry
While shale producers have fortified their finances, OPEC and allied producing countries this week began discussing an output cut of 1.4 million barrels per day (bbl/d) to stem the sharp slide in crude prices. U.S. crude was trading at $57 a barrel on Nov. 15, down $20 from its October high.
OPEC last sought to drive out shale producers by flooding the market with oil in 2014. That production free-for-all lasted nearly two years, sending crude to below $27 a barrel, but while it bloodied shale, it led the industry to become among the globe's lowest-cost oil producers.
Now, any OPEC output cuts that lift global prices should benefit U.S. shale producers. They have become so lean they can profit on each new barrel of oil pumped from West Texas shale fields at $36 a barrel and from North Dakota's Bakken play at $43 a barrel, according to RS Energy Group.
Rather than slowing shale production, the latest price drop could hasten industry consolidation as bigger producers snap up weaker rivals.
"The small guys are going to go away" through mergers, said John Groton Jr., director of equity research at Thrivent Asset Management, which invests in shale operators. He said he believes the companies missing cash flow targets will become prime buyout candidates. "You have buyers who want to grow."
There have been several blockbuster buyouts this year, using stock instead of cash. Encana Corp. (NYSE: ECA) this month offered $5.5 billion in stock for Newfield Exploration Co. (NYSE: NFX). Concho Resources Inc. (NYSE: CXO) kicked off this year's merger wave with an $8 billion all-stock deal for RSP Permian.
Investment banker Tudor Pickering Holt & Co. predicted another 10 shale deals worth $40 billion will surface in 2019.
Consolidation can spread costs over more production, boosting cash. Chesapeake Energy Corp.'s (NYSE: CHK) recent $4 billion cash-and-stock offer for WildHorse Resource Development Corp. (NYSE: WRD) will allow the Oklahoma City-based company to hit cash flow goals in 2020, "much sooner" than it would otherwise, CEO Doug Lawler said last month.
Selling Assets
Other shale firms are selling acreage or service arms to finance production and cover dividends. Pioneer Natural Resources Co. (NYSE: PXD) this week raised $400 million from a pressure pumping unit. It will sell more assets and expects to generate more cash than it consumes next year, CEO Timothy Dove said during a third-quarter earnings call.
RELATED: Pioneer Sells Pressure Pumping Assets To ProPetro For $400 Million
Not everyone thinks the historically boom-or-bust shale business will be able control spending.
Moving to expand drillable reserves and raise production "is in these companies' DNA," said Roy Martin, analyst at energy consultancy Wood Mackenzie. "The future of their business hinges on more barrels coming out," he said.
Clark Williams-Derry, director of energy finance at sustainability think tank Sightline Institute, said producers are trying to restrain spending while still pumping more oil to meet investor demands for cash flow.
"It's an industry that's struggling to maintain production while pleasing investors," Williams-Derry said.
Recommended Reading
Excelerate to Buy LNG, Power Assets from New Fortress for $1.055B
2025-03-27 - Excelerate Energy will buy a New Fortress Energy’s Integrated downstream LNG and power platform in Jamaica in a $1.055 billion cash acquisition.
DNO to Buy Sval Energi for $450MM, Quadruple North Sea Output
2025-03-07 - Norwegian oil and gas producer DNO ASA will acquire Sval Energi Group AS’ shares from private equity firm HitecVision.
Nabors SPAC, e2Companies $1B Merger to Take On-Site Powergen Public
2025-02-12 - Nabors Industries’ blank check company will merge with e2Companies at a time when oilfield service companies are increasingly seeking on-site power solutions for E&Ps in the oil patch.
M&A Target Double Eagle Ups Midland Oil Output 114% YOY
2025-01-27 - Double Eagle IV ramped up oil and gas production to more than 120,000 boe/d in November 2024, Texas data shows. The E&P is one of the most attractive private equity-backed M&A targets left in the Permian Basin.
ConocoPhillips Sells $600MM in Noncore Permian Basin Assets
2025-02-06 - Following its $22.5 billion deal to buy Marathon Oil, ConocoPhillips is targeting $2 billion in asset sales— a goal a company executive said would largely be achieved this year.